Quantcast
X
Find the Best Price
Show Prices Change Dates
Best Hotel Rankings

Best Hotels in Key West

We've ranked the top hotels in Key West based on an unbiased analysis of awards, expert recommendations and user ratings. Out of 10 luxury hotels, three made the U.S. News list of the Best Hotels in Key West. The highest ranked hotels are The Marquesa Hotel and Sunset Key Guest Cottages, A Westin Resort.

Updating ListUpdating List...
Best Hotel in Key West

Named one of the U.S. News
Best Hotels in Key West for 2014

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Excellent
  • Guest Rating

This tiny hotel on Fleming Street beckons to travelers who don't have young kids. In fact, you have to be at ... continue »

Best Hotel in Key West

Named one of the U.S. News
Best Hotels in Key West for 2014

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

This luxurious Westin property is ideal for fulfilling your latest Robinson Crusoe fantasy, seeing as this hotel comprises 7 acres of Sunset ... continue »

Best Hotel in Key West

Named one of the U.S. News
Best Hotels in Key West for 2014

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Moderate
  • Guest Rating

This all-suite hotel, just a block from Key West's lively Duval Street, wins lodgers over with its thoughtful, unique amenities. Some ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

A member of the swanky Noble House hotel group, this harborfront, 100-room property in the upper-left quadrant of Mallory Square adheres to ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

Cleanliness might seem like a given at a luxury hotel, but the guests at Parrot Key don't take it for granted ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

At first, guests are underwhelmed by the 118-room Hyatt Key West Resort; the private man-made beach is much too small, travelers say ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Moderate
  • Guest Rating

The Pier House Resort has all the necessary ingredients of a great Key West hotel: a prime location (just northwest of Mallory ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

Guests with young kids appreciate The Reach Resort's family-friendly vibe with sprawling pools and playground facilities catering to younger travelers. But ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

Travelers praise the location above all else at The Westin Key West Resort & Marina, but then again, any Mallory Square hotel is ... continue »

  • Hotel Class 4.0-star
  • Critic Rating Good
  • Guest Rating

Many of Key West's best hotels are clustered around Mallory Square — but this landmark property (which is listed on the National ... continue »

*Any unranked hotels have been sorted by hotel class and then alphabetically. More information can be found on our methodology page.