Sugar Mill Hotel

Apple Bay | Tortola, Virgin Islands (British) [See Map]
#1 in Best British Virgin Islands Hotels
Hotel Class 4.0-star Critic Rating Good Guest Rating
TripAdvior Traveler Rating

Based on 374 reviews

U.S. News Review

It's hard to determine what travelers enjoy more — the gourmet seafood or the first-rate service at this small Tortola hotel. And that's not surprising as this cottage-turned-hotel is owned and operated by renowned food and travel writers Jefferson and Jinx Morgan. The intimate dining room — complete with mood lighting and an innovative menu — wins over many of its patrons. However, there are a few things you should know before you book: Sugar Mill is located over Apple Bay, along the island's northeast coast and children ages 11 and younger are not permitted to stay at Sugar Mill during the peak season (December to April). Also, keep in mind that Sugar Mill is missing some of the accoutrements you'd find at other luxury properties, like spa treatments and TVs in every room. Despite lacking extravagance, these simplistic accommodations do come equipped with a kitchenette and private balcony overlooking the waterfront or tropical garden.

How we rank hotels

Awards Received

  • Fodor's Choice
  • Frommer's Highly Recommended
  • Lonely Planet Top Pick

Guest Rooms

  • High Price
  • Average Price
  • Low Price
  • Today
  • +1 Week
  • +2 Weeks
  • +3 Weeks

Good Deal

Prices for this hotel   
Prices for similar hotels   
See details for room types »

Guest Reviews

A hotel's guest rating is calculated using data provided under license by TripAdvisor. A total of 374 guests have reviewed the Sugar Mill Hotel, giving it a rating of 5.0, on a scale of 1-5.

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating: 5.0 (based on 374 reviews)

Guest Reviews: Read most recent guest reviews


  • Internet Access
  • Dining
  • Pool

Editor's note: Hotel information is updated periodically. If this is your property and you notice any inaccuracies, please let us know. If you are interested in obtaining a badge to display on your website or in other media, please contact us.

Similar Hotels Nearby

Sugar Mill Hotel

Apple Bay | Tortola, Virgin Islands (British) [See Full Map]